Wednesday, May 14, 2008

CAN A WALL DO A TEACHER`S JOB???

That is the question!

In the course of the week you will be introduced to a number of tools that will be very handy for...

... Well ...

Why don´t you find out for yourself?

All the best! I am really looking forward to this project!

Miss Florence

110 comments:

Anonymous said...

I think that yes in some ways and no in some others.
Tomas P

Anonymous said...

I think is an impossible thing
francisco.f

Miss Florence said...

Can you expand on why both of you think this way? Thank you!

Anonymous said...

I think that when you are a teacher, I mean a real teacher, you know lots of things that a boy or girl doesnt know when he does a presentation for example, when hes playing "the teacher roll" So no one can be such a teacher as a real one, so that is a no. But its also yes because if you have something to share , for example, some information or something to share with the other children, you are playing the "teacher roll". So that is a yes. My final answer is: yes and no. It depends. On knowing things (knowing or not) my answer is no. But I say yes because of course we can all go to the front and say something. YES AND NO
Olivia G E

Anonymous said...

my comment is very long but well.. I said all I had to say and I explained it A LOT. jjaja
Olivia G E

Anonymous said...

I think it is imposible couse walls dont help us when we dont understand something.

AGUSTIN D

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Miss Florence said...

Thank you Oli... Thank you Agustín!
I think you both have been very clear, each one in their own personal way!

Anonymous said...

A wall can do much more than any teacher if it helps to develop our minds and become reflective thinkers. Let's give it a try

Anonymous said...

Hello Mrs Florence!!!
I have visited your Wall, and I really believe the children will learn from it in a very creative and appealing way!! I am longing to see their work and maybe...we can give one of the songs a try!!ji ji ! Enjoy the WALL children!!!I wish my teachers would have taught me in such a variety of ways!!!!!!

Congratulations!!!

Mrs Ceci

Anonymous said...

Miss Florance :
I think that a wall can't do a teachers' roll because teacher's know when you are realy listening and when you're realy interested in something, while a wall can't.
They pay attention to you, and all the time they are giving you tips and advises for you to learn and have a great time in school.
SO I THINK A WALL CAN'T DO A TEACHERS JOB.

Love,

Shany M

Anonymous said...

Hi miss Florence, I think a wall can make the job of the teachers in a way, because it can leave pages with explenations of exercises and home-work but it can´t answer questions although it would be an intresting project to work on...
See you at school...
Andy P. 6B

Anonymous said...

I think a wall can do and can´t do a teachers job in some ways and in other ways, so......YES AND NO but I think more than no because walls don´t help us understand something so Yes and (NOOO NOOO)Martin T

Miss Florence said...

Thank you, Anonymous (Who are you?!) And Ceci, and Shany, Andy and Martín... Interesting!!!!

Anonymous said...

Miss Florence:

I think that a wall can`t do a teachers work because the teachers talk and teach us and a wall can`t even move. We don`t lern anithing from a wall only how to build it and a wall can`t many other things that the teachers do

Bauti C

Miss Florence said...

Thanks, Bauti... For writing and for getting into the blog at this time! It is a great thing to be able to move...

Anonymous said...

I do think a wall can do a teacher´s job, because teacher´s job is to explain and teach things to students and a wall can have it written, but I also think that no, because students can ask questions to teachers, but we can´t ask a question to a wall
goodbye
agus.c

Miss Florence said...

Thanks Agus! It was really late when you posted that comment... We are on holidays, right?

Anonymous said...

Dear miss ale:
I think that a wall can't do a teacher's work because a teacher explains it better and if you have a question a wall can't answer it but a teacher can!! A teacher has much more expirience that a wall, if you don't understand something a wall couldn't explain it in any way but a teacher yes.. because she or he can move, can talk and especially can listen what was your question! To think an answer to these question you have to have common scence!!!!

I'm enjoing a lot these blog!!
Caro.g

Miss Florence said...

Hello Caro... One minor detail... This is not Miss Ale`s blog!!! Thanks for your very nice comment,and I am glad you are enjoying it!!!!

Anonymous said...

Hello Miss Florence
I think that a wall can´t do a teachers job because when you have some questions it can´t answer. Although I think it can do part of a teachers job because it can give you instructions to do something and it can give you a lot of information. I think this project is great and I like it a lot because we can do it in groups with our friends.
See you soon,
Barbie M

Anonymous said...

I THINK IT cant because if its difficult for a human it would be worse for a wall

Anonymous said...

Ithink a wall can do a teachers job because the wall can be writen by information.

SANTI.BO

Miss Florence said...

Thanks, Barbie... Glad you are looking forward to it!

Miss Florence said...

Santi... It was really late! Glad you were blogging... and thanks for your comment!

Miss Florence said...

Who is the annonymous who wrote I Think it is difficult? Could you expand and tell me who you are? Thanks!

Anonymous said...

Miss Florence:
I think a wall can't do a teachers job because i teacher will explain it all better.

Kathi.D

Miss Florence said...

Wow Kathi!!!! YOU the teacher!!! Great!!!!!!

Anonymous said...

Miss Florence, I think its impossible because a wall can't talk and a teacher to a wall can't express its self and a teacher can. The teacher can look at you so they now if every thing is okey or if you are paing attaion but a wall can't. My point is that a wall can't do a teachers roll.
Sofi F

Anonymous said...

I think that the wall can make a teacher´s job, but it has to be very very specific because if you have a doupt you cant ask it to the wall because they dont talk and to be so specific its very dificult because each student has his own question. So my conclusion its that its possible but very difficult.
Luis G

Anonymous said...

A wall really can´t do a teachers job because it isn´t a living thing but in another way if you put something that may catch the atention of the children it will help a lot

Iñaki S

Miss Florence said...

Thanks Sofi for your opinion... and Luis... I like your input as well!

See you tomorrow!

Miss Florence said...

I`m glad you consider us teachers alive, Iñaqui!! Ha! Ha! Thanks!!!!!!

Anonymous said...

Miss Florence:
I think a wall can´t do a teacher`s job because it has to be very specific no to leave doubts and the wall would have to be inmense to be specific and would be boring and no one would pay any attention so no one would learn while with teachers you can ask questions and learn from your and others mistakes and it is more intresting by doing experiments.
Thank you

Felipe M

Miss Florence said...

Thank you for your opinions, Felipe! Good to know you prefer us to a wall!!!!!

Anonymous said...

I think that being a teacher is a great job bt difficult in some ways and you really need to know things!!!
vicente.mf

Anonymous said...

Miss Florence
I think that a wall could do a teacher's job, but in some things, a wall could teach us but you Miss Florence, When we have a quiestion a wall can't answer it you can, We feel better having a real person talking to us and moving around, and express her ideas etc.. So my concluiton really is that a wall can't do a teacher's job!
Nicole D. 6a
For next time I will put Kiki for my name as I do in Miss Ale's blog.

Anonymous said...

Miss Florence
I think that a wall could do a teacher's job, but in some things, a wall could teach us but you Miss Florence, When we have a quiestion a wall can't answer it you can, We feel better having a real person talking to us and moving around, and express her ideas etc.. So my concluiton really is that a wall can't do a teacher's job!
Nicole D. 6a

Anonymous said...

I think a wall can do a teacher's job because the wall can be writen by any information.

Anonymous said...

Yes. if it has lots of signs and it is really big yes.
Lucas C.

Anonymous said...

Miss Ale
I think a wall in some cases could do a teacher's job,, for example a wall can teach us, but if we have a question the wall can't answer it but you a real teacher yes! You can express you ideas, by acting or giving examples and you can make it more interesting for us to learn! But a wall is just flat with papers written on it!
So my conclution is that a wall can't do ALL the teacher's job.
Nicole D6a

Anonymous said...

Hi Miss Florence,
I think that it is a no because a teacher knows a lot of things but wall couldn't go at the front of all a class and give a lesson. A wall isn't a living thing so i think it is a no.

Anonymous said...

Hi Miss Florence,
I think it is a no because a wall can't go to the front of a whole class and start giving a lesson. A teacher knows much more than a wall. Y answer i think is a no.

Lucia V

Miss Florence said...

Wow! I am glad to see how many have blogged! Good to see there are people that compare living and non living things!
Lucy... Thanks for your comment!

Anonymous said...

NO because a wall can say something, but the teacher can explain it much better that the information on the wall


teo d

Miss Florence said...

Thank you Teo for blogging and welcome!

Anonymous said...

Hello Florence, I think a wall can`t to a teachers job because if you don`tundrstand something I can`t ask the wal but I can ask the teacherif I have a question. A wall also can if it has a lot of imformation there and if there are instructions on the wall.


Ramiro T

Miss Florence said...

Thank you for your comment, Ramiro!

Anonymous said...

I think that yes, because on a wall you can put posters and things to explain it with details and it can bring interest to who is seen what is on that wall.
Tomas.S

Anonymous said...

Hello, P Chica pupils! Welcome to my blog!

Anonymous said...

Punta Chica boys and girls... WELCOME!!!
Miss Florence

Anonymous said...

I think nothig can teach us brtter than a teacher!

Anonymous said...

I think that yes a wall can do a teachers job because they could be written information there that may be useful to make a progect or to study...
GREAT BLOG!!!!!
Simon S

Anonymous said...

Y think that a wall cant do a teachers job because the teacher is there for all the questions you need but the wall is not alive and it cant give you answers.
Tobias.M

Miss Florence said...

Oops! Who are you, 5.18 pm??????

Miss Florence said...

Thanks, Simon! That will keep me blogging!!!!!

Miss Florence said...

Thanks, Tobías!!! yes... we can talk!

Anonymous said...

A teacher is alive,the wall no.So a wall cannot do the job.
Marina D.

Anonymous said...

I think a wall can Teacher´s job because all the information the teacher knows they can put it on the wall and the students can read from there, and they can put photos so they understand better.But If someone down´t understand the wall can´t talk so the wall can´t explain.

Ezequiel Y.

Miss Florence said...

Short, but to the point! Good for you, Marina!

Miss Florence said...

So, Eze? What is your final conclusion????

Anonymous said...

No because can not explain our doubts or give us instruction to do a work or experiments.But sometimes its they can do the teachers job because you can write istruction like we do with Cesar Milstein. So the wall can do the work of teacher but, the teacher is better.

Facundo G

Miss Florence said...

Thanks Facu... I think the words I most appreciate are the last four!!!!

Anonymous said...

Miss Florence:
I think a wall can't do a teacher's job, because although we can go and read from the wall you had to put all the signs and that stuff.
Thanks!,
Maiu F.

Anonymous said...

Another thing I forgot to say in the last comment is that a wall can't answer questions!!
Maiu F.

Anonymous said...

No because first the wall can do the work of the teacher, but the teacher always will be better and wil do bettar. But sometimes its they can do the teachers job because you can write istruction like we are doing with the work of Cesar Milstein.
Martin T

Miss Florence said...

Thanks Maiu... for thinking in what I do! By the way... who are you? Ha Ha!

Miss Florence said...

Thanks, Martín... be better and do better? Wow! Thanks again!

Anonymous said...

Hi Miss Florence!

I think that a wall can do a teachers´s job but not as well as a teacher does it because the teacher can explain you with easier words and you can ask her at the moment she is explaining.

Angeles R.S.

Miss Florence said...

Hello, Angie! Thanks!

Anonymous said...

I think that they could work as a team I mean the wall and the teacher. EXAMPLE: Miss Florence said us to read the wall that she prepared with some pages stuck so we would read the pages and inform us. That is an example Miss Florence prepared the work, and the wall show it to us .So in some ways yes and in another ways no. Equally somebody has to put posters or right in the wall, stick exercises etc on the wall so the pupils would read and work with.

Delfina G.

Anonymous said...

I think that it can do it in some ways but the teacher can explain some things and help you if you do not understand so i think that no.
Juan G. 6B

Anonymous said...

I don`t really think so because a wall cant have experienced what a teacher has because a wall is not alive and needs someone to post something and if someone does not post something you can`t learn anything from a wall.

Francisco.V

Miss Florence said...

Thank you Delfi... Nice comment. Juan, your comment was also very useful to me! Francisco...thanks for considering me! Have a great day!

Anonymous said...

Florence: I think that a wall can do teacher´s work because you can write what you want them to learn and children read it and know all about it.


Nicolas.H.

Anonymous said...

Florence: I thik that yes because maybe that wall is a computer.

Marcos.P.I

Anonymous said...

Florence: for me no because nothig can teach better than a teacher.

tomas.c

Anonymous said...

I think a wall can't because the teacher can talk and teach and see what we do. And the only thing a wall can do is protect, hide or cover something.
Malcolm H

Anonymous said...

I think it is posible.


Are we going to do instantly ice?



Felipe.W

Anonymous said...

yes, for me a wall can do the work of a teacher because in a wall you can put everything you need to know and put all the works.



MARK.L

Miss Florence said...

What a phrase, Tomas! Thanks!

Miss Florence said...

Thanks, Malcolm!

Anonymous said...

Hi Miss Florence:
I am Maia F. from 6A Punta Chica
bye!

Miss Florence said...

Hello, Maia! COld, isn´t it??

Anonymous said...

Miss Florence
I think that a wall can´t do a teacher´s job but i don´t still fully understan what it means. Although I think that it means that you don´t have to throw to the floor the posters that you put on the wall.

Felipe S

Miss Florence said...

I agree with you Felipe... Do you really think it has to do with the throwing of posters? Let me put it this way... Do walls and teachers have things in common...or not?

Anonymous said...

Hello Mrs. Florence! I like the page very much! It is great. I think that a wall can do a teacher´s job because maybe the wall can say everything the teacher has to say in a lesson. But also no because a teacher can explain much better and more complete things than a wall can do so you can understand better. So it is yes and no.

Lola.L

Anonymous said...

Yes, it is really cold.
Have a great weekend!,
Maia F.

Anonymous said...

no, I think that no because if you dont understand walls cant talk. Sciencetists are advancing a lot but i think there will never be a talking wall. This is a very good blog!!!

Matias PAB

Anonymous said...

I think that no because the teacher can put photos and information that the teacher knows and that is working but if I go to see the wall and I don't andurstand it like what does it say or what does it mean the wall can't explein it to me.

Josefina B.

Miss Florence said...

Thanks Matías! Thanks Josefina! Sleep tight, and cover up! It is FREEZING!

Anonymous said...

hi miss florence I think it can do part of a teachers job but the teacher has to be there to explain all the things about it. Our group is enjoying the project of the wall. good project

bye bye
Thomas D

Miss Florence said...

Thanks for your praise, Tomas! It does us good!

Anonymous said...

I think that yes and that no because you can read information and learn and no because if you have a question you can not ask the wall.

lucas beller

Anonymous said...

Hello mrs. Florence!!!!

I think that a wall can and can't do a teacher's job because you can learn from reading a wall but a teacher would tell you more things or could anwnser a question that you ask.

Lucas Beller

Anonymous said...

Florence: i think that yes a wall can do a teacher job but hs to be big and very specific is really difficult but could help a lot.

Nico.G.

Miss Florence said...

Hi Lucas and Nico! Thanks for your comments!

Anonymous said...

I think that a wal can´t do a teachers job because nobody teach better than a teacher...

Bye

Martina V

Anonymous said...

Hello Florence the blog is great! It is super interesting and cool thanks for responding my comment! Bye thank you!


Jose B.

Miss Florence said...

Martu... Short and sweet! Thanks!

Miss Florence said...

Jose, you deserve it!

Anonymous said...

Thanks for this blog it helps me alot..... Because now I know much more about scientists that I would never would read about.
Excellent blog again!!!
Simon S

Miss Florence said...

Thanks Simon! Words like yours keep me very motivated!!!!

Anonymous said...

Hi Florence i think that the blog is great it is a good idea to learn interesting things about science in another way.However thanks for responding my coment.

Delfina G.

Miss Florence said...

Delfi, thanks for such an uplifting comment!!!

Anonymous said...

I think that in some ways yes because it can have information written on it but it cannot think nor speak.

lucas G

Anonymous said...

OH miss Florence it is a great idea for you and for all of us. I think this way because this wall can teach us some biographies in a easier way and we are going to have fun and we are having fun!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ines G.

Miss Florence said...

Thank you, Inés! You really help me move ahead with your nice words!

Anonymous said...

Miss Florence:
I think the blog is an excellent idea, but I think that in a way it's like more homework for YOU!
love
Maia F.

Anonymous said...

the wall cant do a teacher job because teachers exlain , show , teach you many thing . The wall Can JUST HAVE information but it can t do all the things a teacher does .
max.k